Tuesday, December 22, 2009
The market for “nice” investment bankers..
I recently read an article in ToI about an amusement arcade game called ‘Whack the Banker’ which was proving to be a big hit in the UK. The media of course, with predictable regularity profiles the greed and avarice of alpha male bulge bracket investment bankers who snatch food from the mouths of starving, homeless people to pad their own pockets. These are of course facetious extremes; reality probability lies somewhere in between.
In our own interactions with investment bankers, especially those in the mid market segment, we’ve generally seen a fairly well ingrained sense of ethics and fair play. Of course, we’ve had the odd case where a banker deliberately misrepresented facts about their client or tried to go behind our backs and poach our client. This said, the one aspect of i-banker behaviour we’d definitely like to change is the unnecessary posturing and game-playing that is almost de rigueur for every banker driven deal. I strongly believe that there is absolutely no gain in value that is derived from such posturing and it adds 20-30% to the time a deal takes to close. An honest dialogue between the bankers representing both sides of a deal will probably achieve better results for both parties and save a lot of time for all concerned.
At Viedea, we’ve always believed in the value of being honest, straight-forward responsive bankers who work with like minded clients. In fact, that is our USP in many ways, along with the emphasis on quality – quality clients, quality deals, quality employees and quality work. There is a market for “nice” investment bankers after all!
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
Education : The new holy grail for VC/PE's
Ask any VC in
Let’s focus on education to try and understand where the real opportunity lies.
VC/PE investors naturally recognize the potential returns investing in this sector can offer. Based on proprietary research by our education sector team, we present a ‘below the hood’ peek into the sub-sectors that form the education pie-
1. School/College Management – If fund managers had their way, they would probably want to run a chain of schools (K12- Kindergarten to class 12) or colleges, with what ever focus (premium vs mid/low income) they deem fit. However, owing to regulatory & to some extent social obligations, schools and colleges in India have to be managed by a not-for profit entity (trust), thereby forcing ‘for profit’ enterprises to largely stay away from the ‘business’ of schools.
Recently we have seen investments by funds in pre-school chains and several private companies engaged in allied businesses taking ownership of school management. Some companies have worked their way around by differentiating the school ownership entity (trust) & school management entity which profits from land lease rentals, supply of IP, hardware, etc. However, we do not believe that school/college management is an attractive investment proposition for funds under the present regulatory conditions.
2. Information and Communication Technology (ICT) for Educational institutions:The ICT opportunity comprises technology solutions for learning, hardware, infrastructure, multimedia content, institution & student management systems, etc, for K12 and higher education.
The ICT business has matured, with strong competition between the established (mostly funded or listed!) players such as Educomp,
While ICT is an obviously large market opportunity, we believe that the key to scaling up is the ability to sell to government. Private schools may fetch higher margins, but the sheer volumes that government sale offers is vital for a private ICT player to scale up. Moreover, higher education, which has no nationwide common syllabus like ICSE/CBSE, is also largely untapped by ICT players and presents a potential opportunity.
3 3. Test prep and Tutorials: Test preparation coaching and tuitions have co-existed with traditional teaching and are an integral part of the Indian education system, especially in urban
Our hypothesis is that there is an opportunity for a nation wide test prep play through a strong blended model, combining brick and mortar with online delivery. While there is no success story yet to demonstrate this, with a clever combination of easy to use technology and good execution, we will witness a few success stories in this space in the coming years.
Online tuitions for school students we believe, is also catching up and scaling up is relatively easier. The nay-sayers can use statistical data about broadband penetration being low, but the absolute number of students using internet as a source of knowledge has gone up and there are only a limited number of tuition/coaching providers who are catering to them through the blended model.
4 4. Vocational Training: Nasscom and every other survey on the formal education system in
5 5. E-learning technology and content development: Within the outsourcing space, Indian companies have developed capabilities in development & consequently implementation of E-learning initiatives plus learning management systems (LMS) for corporate clients as well as educational institutions. The development and conversion of content for publishers & educational institutions, especially for the
The sectors discussed above are not exhaustive; however, a majority of deals one is likely to see in the education space will fall into one of these buckets. As in any investment, the quality of the management team is probably the most critical factor, apart from the market opportunity they are addressing. For more information on education sector opportunities and interesting companies in the space, please contact Aravind G.R (aravind@viedea.com) or Deepak Srinath (deepak@viedea.com).
Thursday, February 12, 2009
Retail debacle:
‘Bird of Gold’ with reference to the ‘Soney ki Chidiya’ , a mascot of sorts to the Pantaloon Group and title of the famed report by Mckinsey, perhaps was the defining phrase for the Indian retail story, until now!.We were always being served by the local kirana shop (there is one such store for every 100 people) and then came the era of organized retailing. The promise of a bird of gold in the hands of the burgeoning middle class seemed so easy to catch, for all those who had deep pockets (capital). However, Subiksha and Vishal have recently announced closure of one third of their stores. Reliance, Tatas & Birla have almost shelved their expansion plans & are about to close many of their existing outlets. The third quarter results of listed retail companies also depict their precarious state of operations.Declining margins may be attributed by some to increasing costs of debt & real estate (yes, most of the retailers had locked in their rates) but explaining decline in sales is hard. Same Store Sales growth (once you remove sales due to new stores added) reveals that the actual sales have not just slowed down, but declined. The Indian growth story was largely fueled by the increased spending by middle class hypothesis, this decline in sales should come as a serious blow to the ‘strong fundamentals’ theory.‘Bottom of the Pyramid’ now seems like a mirage, but we believe it is not. The consumption story of India remains, but organized retail is loosing its part in it. The problem, as R Subramanian (MD, Subhiksha) puts it, ‘Indian retail was doing too much, too soon’. Companies poured in billions of rupees into building outlets at a frenzied pace. Reliance had plans of 2,000; Subhiksha actually opened 1,500 outlets in 2 years; Pantaloon opened dozens of new formats (including one which was supposed to sell candles). All of this ‘leveraged’ investment happened at the front end, whereas the modern format of retailing relies heavily on the backend (supply chains); except a few like Pantaloon & Reliance, none of the retailers invested & strengthened their supply chains. Now, Subramanian admits ‘It was no wonder that, for most new entrants, the expansion was a disaster waiting to happen’. These retailers who faced increased costs in goods, salaries and through inefficient supply chains; were pushed to increase the prices, thereby not delivering on their promise of being the cheapest seller. We started going back to our trusted old friend at the street corner shop.The way out (is there one?) or the way going forward- Those who continue to deliver the promise of being cheap & efficient will continue to thrive on gold. Cutting costs and reworking their system is top priority for the retailers who are hurt. We believe that a sound retailing model should always be backed by support/supply system, without which the advantage of organized retail format is lost.
Tuesday, January 06, 2009
LPO Prospects in India
LPO as an industry in India is in a nascent stage. The industry is highly fragmented with over 100 firms operating in different verticals. According to a report by ValueNotes, the revenues from legal services offshoring are forecast to grow from $146 million in 2006 to $640 million by the end of 2010. Forrester Research projects that $4 billion in legal work is likely to come to India by 2015. Currently, the size of the industry is small (especially, considering the number of players operating) but the growth prospects are good. It is obvious that many entrepreneurs jumped in to catch a pie of this lucrative industry. But the fact is that only a handful of companies in India are doing well and most of others are still small and suffering. The lack of preparedness while staring the business has led to quality issues as well.
No doubt the industry holds tremendous prospects, but it is critical to understand the industry dynamics which are specific to LPO. Cost benefits are definitely a top consideration for the firms who would like to outsource legal work to India. The cost of getting work done from India could be as low as 20% of what it is in the US. Availability of manpower is not a big constraint in India as thousands of students graduate from Indian law schools and engineering colleges (engineers are needed to execute work related to IP/Patent research). However, training them to carry out the foreign legal work is important and this needs investment. Association with a foreign law firm would be extremely helpful in building the LPO business. This helps in knowledge transfer as well as assurance as far as client base is considered. Signing in a legal client is not a simple task unless there is some backing by a foreign legal firm or you have sales persons who are well connected in the industry.
There is interest from the investor community in the industry. Firms such as Clutch Group, Pangea3, United Lex, Mindcrest and TechLit have been funded by angel investors and VCs.
We believe that LPO is certainly a good space to jump in, but one needs to focus on certain key aspects to be successful:
- Cost benefit is an obvious consideration while outsourcing – every player in the industry offers it. But being quality conscious is extremely important to be successful and to grow the business. The challenge for the Indian LPOs is to convince the firms outsourcing the legal work, about quality of output.
- Investment in training and devising right training techniques is important.
- Industry connection/network is critical – either through foreign law firms’ association or through a well connected sales force
- Confidentiality - this is an important aspect any legal client would expect from LPO firms while executing the assignments. Therefore, implementing measures to take care of this and winning client's confidence is of great importance.
We also believe that as the industry becomes more competitive, small and inefficient players may be forced out of business and we could also witness some consolidation happening in the industry.